Structuring Your Novel: Plotting vs. Pantsing Explained

When embarking on the journey of writing a novel, one of the most crucial decisions authors face is how to structure their story. The two primary approaches to this process are plotting and pantsing, each offering unique advantages and potential pitfalls. In this article, we will delve into the definitions, pros and cons of each method, and provide insights to help you determine which approach might be best for your writing style.

Understanding Plotting and Pantsing

Before we explore the intricacies of both methods, it’s essential to define what plotting and pantsing mean in the context of novel writing.

• Plotting: This approach involves thorough planning before writing any part of the novel. Plotters typically outline their story, creating detailed character arcs, chapter summaries, and essential plot points in advance. This method can lead to a well-structured narrative, ensuring that all elements work cohesively toward a satisfying conclusion.

• Pantsing: Derived from the phrase “flying by the seat of your pants,” pantsing is the opposite of plotting. Writers who adopt this style often begin their stories with a vague idea or concept and let the narrative unfold organically as they write. This method can lead to unexpected plot twists and character developments that would not have occurred in a strictly outlined framework.

Example Structures

Many successful authors employ elements of both plotting and pantsing, creating a hybrid approach that suits their individual writing processes. Notable examples include:

• J.K. Rowling: Best known for the Harry Potter series, Rowling has spoken about her meticulous planning process for her novels. This structure allowed her to weave intricate subplots and character arcs throughout the series.

• Stephen King: In contrast, King often embraces the pantser approach, letting his characters dictate the story as it unfolds. His novel Misery was written using this method, resulting in a tense and unpredictable narrative.

Pros and Cons of Plotting

Advantages of Plotting

1. Clarity and Structure: A thorough outline provides a clear direction for the story. Writers can visualize the entire plot arc, ensuring that all plot points tie together logically.

2. Goal-Oriented Writing: Plotters can set specific writing goals based on their outline. With clear milestones, such as completing a chapter or pivotal scene, progress becomes measurable and manageable.

3. Fewer Dead Ends: By planning characters’ motivations and plot points, writers can avoid getting stuck or writing themselves into corners, which often leads to frustration and rewriting.

Disadvantages of Plotting

1. Reduced Flexibility: Rigid outlines can stifle creativity, making writers feel constrained. If the story evolves in unexpected ways, plotters may struggle to adjust their outlines to accommodate new ideas.

2. Less Exploration: Plotters may miss the opportunity to fully explore character development in the writing process. When bound to an outline, characters may not grow organically, as they are often tied to predetermined arcs.

3. Pressure to Perfection: The desire to follow the outline flawlessly may lead to self-imposed pressure to perfect every detail before proceeding, which can perpetuate writer's block.

Pros and Cons of Pantsing

Advantages of Pantsing

1. Creative Freedom: Pantsers enjoy the freedom to explore their imagination. As ideas come and go, their creative process blooms, allowing for spontaneous bursts of inspiration.

2. Character-Driven Stories: Since pantsers allow the characters to evolve naturally, those stories often feel more authentic. Characters are free to change based on their experiences, leading to surprise developments.

3. Flexibility in Writing: When stories develop organically, the structure can adapt to unforeseen plot twists. This flexibility can result in engaging narrative shifts that keep both the writer and readers intrigued.

Disadvantages of Pantsing

1. Potential for Chaos: Without a clear plan, pantsers may struggle with plot coherence. It can be easy to wander off course, resulting in a lack of focus in the narrative.

2. Increased Rewriting: The organic nature of pantsing often leads to discovering thematic inconsistencies or plot holes. As a result, these writers may end up rewriting significant sections of their manuscript.

3. Difficulty in Goal Setting: Pantsers may find it hard to establish goals due to the unpredictable nature of their writing process. This can lead to feelings of being overwhelmed, especially during long writing projects.

Finding Your Personal Approach

While plotting and pantsing represent two ends of the writing spectrum, most authors find themselves somewhere in-between. Here are some strategies to discover what works best for you:

1. Experimentation: Try both styles in different writing projects. You might begin with a detailed outline for one novel and let another evolve organically. Look for what feels more satisfying and productive.

2. Create a Flexible Outline: If you lean towards plotting but desire some freedom, consider creating a flexible outline that allows for adjustments as you write. This method can help guide your narrative without stifling creativity.

3. Character Journals: If you’re excited about pantsing, consider keeping detailed journals for your characters. This can provide structure without imposing constraints, helping you generate plot ideas based on character-driven decisions.

4. Utilize Story Creation Tools: Various resources, including writing prompts and structure outlines, can provide guidance while enabling creative exploration. Websites like Plot Generator and books such as Save the Cat! by Blake Snyder can be invaluable.

Blending Plotting and Pantsing

Many writers find that a combination of plotting and pantsing—often referred to as "planting"—works best for them. This hybrid approach allows for a sense of structure while keeping the door open for creativity. Here are some tips for blending the two methods:

Outlining Key Plot Points

Start by outlining major plot points or pivotal scenes, allowing for structure without detailing the entire process. This keeps the main story arc clear while permitting room for spontaneity in character development and subplots.

Character Exploration

Build in character exercises that explore their backgrounds, motivations, and potential arcs. This adaptable framework allows for organic growth during the writing process.

Regular Check-Ins

Schedule regular check-ins with your outline to ensure you're staying on track. Adjust the outline as needed to reflect new ideas that arise during writing. This strategy brings the best of both worlds into your writing routine.

Conclusion

Structuring your novel is a highly personal affair, influenced by your preferences, writing style, and the specific demands of the story you wish to tell. Understanding the distinctions between plotting and pantsing, along with their pros and cons, will empower you to make informed decisions about your writing process and lead you to create compelling narratives.

Whether you choose to meticulously plan every detail or embark on an unpredictable creative journey, remember that there is no one "right" way to write a novel. The most crucial aspect is to write in a manner that resonates with you, harnessing your unique voice and creativity to craft a story that captivates both you and your readers.

As you embark on this adventure, embrace the process, experiment with different styles, and let your imagination guide you. Happy writing!

Additional Resources

• Writers’ Guild of Great Britain: Provides resources, advice, and networking for writers.
• NaNoWriMo: Offers challenges and community support for writers looking to complete a novel in a month.
• The Creative Penn: A resource for aspiring authors that covers topics from writing to marketing and publishing.

By exploring resources that provide insights into the writing process, you can enhance your skills and confidence while delving into the world of novel writing.

---

With both plotters and pantsers providing their unique strengths and approaches, understanding what resonates with you can help shape your writing journey. Embrace the exploration, enjoy the crafting, and let your story unfold!